1.29.2009
Innovation is a subersive act
1.16.2009
Does innovation work when it's too innovative?


1.08.2009
How does this work...really?
In order to change or improve something, understanding "how things really work" should be essential. And yet, innovation efforts quite often start without anyone challenging the official version of the truth. An obvious example right now would be the US auto industry, where innovators wasted much of their time, resources and labor improving something that may not have been that important to customers...at least not important enough to pay for it when it became expensive.
In the 1990's and early 2000's, US car buyers could purchase cars with more and more power. The conventional thinking was that since consumers enjoyed powerful cars and since they continued to buy them, they must really want more powerful cars. The logical extension of this "official version" of the market was that larger, more powerful cars would always command a greater market share and price premiums. Innovation resources at GM, Chrysler and Ford focused on delivering more power every year - and they delivered admirably. Sales continued to do very well throughout that period as the roads clogged up with SUV's, muscle cars, and ever larger pick up trucks.
But...no matter how big their trucks became, the American car companies continued to lose market share to companies like Toyota and Honda...even when American cars cost less money...
Meanwhile, non-US manufactures continued to improve the efficiency of their cars. A few attempts at producing large non-US cars (usually manufactured in the US) were relatively successful, but they never stopped making efficient small cars. And every year, their market share increased. Every year, even though the conventional thinking was that US car buyers preferred to buy large and powerful engines - companies with smaller engines sold more.
Was "the way things really work" different than we thought?
After a protracted war and conflict in oil producing countries, increased awareness of environmental threats and an unprecedented volatility in gas prices, American cars and trucks stopped selling. And Toyota kept growing.
But how could that be? Americans love their muscle cars and trucks, don't they? At least, that's the official version of the truth.
The un-official version? Perhaps most Americans - like everyone else in the world - don't put that much priority on horse power. Something else probably drives their purchasing behavior - and it just looks like they are addicted to muscle. Otherwise, if horse power were truly a dominant reason to buy a car, buyers would make whatever sacrifices necessary to keep buying it - even as oil prices fluctuate and global warming becomes an accepted context.
This was an easy trap, and almost everyone has at some time or another fallen into it. The official version of the truth - although useful for continuing the existing order of things - is very deceptive when it comes to innovation or preparing for future change.
Good innovators rarely believe the official truth. To innovate almost requires one to be skeptical - even subversive - when considering the established order of things. That's why, when considering innovation, it can help to use a single word, "Really".
The next time you are asked to improve something, make sure you are ready to ask, "really?" early and often.
A proposed "Really" method for innovation preparation
Step One - determine how it works now...really...when a customer buys, uses, displays and disposes of your product/service/process, ask "why?" Start with the official version of reality, then ask the question, "Is that REALLY what happens?". Probe, ask questions, determine what the actual motivations, actions and functions are - not the perceived value - the real value.
Step Two - determine what isn't working...really... where is the pain, what stinks about a product, service or process? Where do people feel most frustrated? How do they work around what stinks? How are they overcoming your lousy output? What are the band-aides? What is the alternative?
Step Three - What do we want...really... start with an official version of what people want - then ask "really?" Is that what we really want? Is there something else that would be even better? What do we really hope to accomplish? What does that look like?
When you understand what really happens, what really isn't working, and what people really want, you may have a foundation for meaningful innovation.
Really.
12.16.2008
Does innovation count if no one pays for it?
12.04.2008
Is it Marketing or is it Nagging?
Inside organizations, when an individual or small group comes up with an idea, innovation, or plan of action, they hone it, make sure that they have worked out how best to make it work, how best to implement. Then, when the plans are all in place, they decide to "communicate" it to whomever has to live with the new idea.
Most professionals have spent time with change management and six sigma consultants. Well-trained employees talk about gaining "buy-in" for an idea - of communicating with key people and getting them to support the idea. In marketing departments, a value proposition is carefully constructed and then a series of communication strategies are used to communicate that value proposition to the target market. In politics, the message masters hone their talking points, then repeat them until the voters can recite them verbatim. Professionals are using a communications formula.
But the formula rarely works as well as it should. People hear the messages, but they don't always believe it. Audiences lose interest. Markets enjoy the commercials but don't buy the products. Voters focus more on a sigh than on a platform position. Why is that?
Perhaps there's more to communication than the current formula? Perhaps our assumptions about communication are flawed?
A central assumption is that communication is a one-way activity. The communicator talks and the audience receives the message. But look at the word "communication" itself. The first half of the word is "commun" - a root for "community" and "commune". Does this suggest that communicating is a group activity? And if it is, why do our formulas for communicating tend to only work in one direction: I talk and you listen?
As a test of that assumption, imagine your own family communications. Can a wife effectively persuade a husband telling him to put away his shoes over and over again? Can a father persuade a teen-age son to avoid smoking with a series of bullet points? Perhaps...but family counselors and other experts seem to suggest that a more effective (and more enjoyable) approach maybe to enter into a real conversation with family members, find out why they are doing what they are doing, make clear that you understand and value their point of view, discuss together how it might be possible to change - and maybe even come to a decision together that neither one thought of before.
Another way to look at it is - when you commune, you are learning. Communicating requires that you learn from the people you communicate to - what they need, what they want, what they know, how they might help solve a problem, how they can help you to do better. Too often, the assumption is that the speaker knows something and therfore needs to place that knowledge with the listener.
And why then, even though nagging family members doesn't work so well, do we insist on nagging our customers, colleagues and constituents? Why do we hire advertising and PR firms to nag the markets with greater skill and polish than we could manage? Why are we nagging?Instead of working on becoming more and more accomplished nags, perhaps we should change our assumptions and stop nagging altogether.
What would a company look like if it changed the communication assumption in order to listen and learn from the people?
A few months ago in the New York Times, I saw a company that has begun to find out. (http://www.nytimes.com/2008/03/01/business/01nocera.html?pagewanted=1) Mickey Drexler, the current CEO of the retailer J.Crew, has managed quite a turnaround for the company. As described by the NYT, key to his process is a constant and in-depth conversation with his customers and his employees.
"Visiting stores, quizzing the staff, critiquing everything in sight — and most of all, meeting customers — is at the core of how Mr. Drexler runs J. Crew. It’s also what makes him happiest. "
Mr. Drexler is known throughout the J.Crew chain for showing up in a store and talking with customers and salespeople and finding out what they like, what they don't like, what works and what doesn't. He delights in trying to persuade someone to put on a new outfit and tell him what they think of it. Instead of telling customers what they should buy, he asks customers what he should offer.
Mr. Drexler has found a way to market to his customers by constantly learning from them. He communicates the company's mission, values and strategy by listening to associates and customers - by "communing" with them.
How can other companies stop nagging their customers and commune like Mr. Drexler?
11.25.2008
What is marketing...really?
10.19.2008
A Few New Rules for Persuasion
Sales, marketing, leadership...all require that we get someone to do something they don't want to do - to change what their doing - to transform some aspect of their work or their life. There are a plethora of books, management training and consultant practices designed to help you manage, or lead change - and yet most people and organizations aren't very good at it.
Soren Kierkegaard once wrote, "...in order to save men's souls, one must first seduce them." Perhaps we need to improve our ability to "seduce" or "persuade" others?
But we have entire disciplines and industries dedicated to persuasion. Marketing is supposed to work magic - to persuade the masses to buy something they don't want. But how is it that companies can spend millions of dollars on award-winning advertising, but not sell more products? US auto manufactures are spending more on advertising today than they did when they had a commanding market share. The best ads from the best advertising firms only seem to work some of the time, even though advertisers are well trained, are following all the rules of good advertising, and have produced some of the best design, drama, music and humour in our culture today. Insurance ads can make me cry pretty reliably, but I still won't buy their annuities.
Why do public speakers, when they follow all the rules given to them in public speaking courses, still bore their audiences? It's difficult to stay awake when a speaker actually follows the template that we all had to learn in our high school and college public speaking courses.
How can a salesman, trained in the art of closing a sale, still be ineffective? When I was a salesman, I remember a sales manager giving up on explaining how to close in any scientific way. Most of the time he attributed it to "magic" when someone pulled it off.
The best professionals all follow the rules that they were given for persuading others...but so few pull it off. Could it be that they are following the wrong rules?
I think so.
Allow me here to map out a few rules that I have discovered that are very useful for "seducing men's souls". This is by no means comprehensive...and I find myself discoving new "rules" all the time - whether from my clients or from observation.
These rules can help a clumsy speaker persuade more effectively than a slick, polished orator. These rules can help a company create a powerful brand identity and grow sales without spending millions of dollars on advertising. And most important, these rules can help a leader persuade people to follow, to change, to transform - even if the leader doesn’t look or sound like a charismatic leader.
Seven New Rules of Persuasion
- Be what you are.
Pretending you’re something that you are not is not only dishonest; it undermines your ability to persuade. A speaker with a poor vocabulary that tries to impress with “big words” will appear less intelligent. A speaker that says, “I’m not that bright, but here’s what I know,” creates credibility. A company that promotes itself with impossibly grand or superlative statements can seem disingenuous, while a direct, honest, and simple statement can become far more inspirational – if it’s real.
But it’s difficult to communicate what you are if you don’t know what that is. Much of my time as a consultant is spent helping companies and individuals understand their strengths, weaknesses and differentiators. Understand - then be what you are.
Persuade authentically. - Tell the truth
One should be honest, not only because it’s the right thing to do, but because it is more persuasive. Few believe a person who only talks about how great they are; everyone believes someone who can communicate their own limitations.
And the limitations can usually demonstrate an attractive strength. For example, “Our airline only serves peanuts, but the flight will be inexpensive.”
Persuade honestly. - Differentiation Means Different
It’s generally understood that differentiation helps clarify value; that customers need to know how you, your product or vision is different and perhaps better than the alternatives. In practice, however, most communicate how similar they are to others. This often happens when a company or person doesn’t understand what makes them different, or when say what they think their audience wants to hear. That’s why, just as in rule #1, it’s essential to understand who you are and what makes you different.
Differences are persuasive because they stand out, because they draw attention, because when making a choice between similar options, only the differences are important.
Persuade differently. - One Thing
A speech, an advertisement, a sales pitch – should always be about One Thing, because that is all your potential listener can act on or remember at any one time. Multiple themes diffuse the communication and its effect.
The temptation “to educate” or to communicate every detail of a subject must be avoided at all costs. Instead, select the most persuasive thesis, and then support that thesis with three of the most persuasive facts.
Persuade single-mindedly. - “The good, if brief, twice good; the bad, if little, less bad.”
The above rule was actually formulated by the seventeenth century Jesuit priest and philosopher, Baltasar Gracian. It speaks for itself.
Persuade briefly. - Lather, Rinse, Repeat…as Needed
This rule was lifted from the back of a shampoo bottle, but also applies to persuasion. The greater a change one asks people to make, the more often they will have to be exposed to and reflect upon the persuasive argument. But don’t just say the same thing over and over again. If someone hears an idea from multiple perspectives, in different contexts, and at different times, they are more likely to take that idea on as their own.
Persuade repeatedly. - Give credit away
The most persuasive idea is the one we come up with ourselves. If that is the case, the most effective persuader will work to make everyone believe it is their own idea. Holding on to credit for a great idea is not as important as getting people to do what you want them to do.
Persuade humbly.